quarter eagles
The Great Quarter Eagle Crack Out
An MS-61 Quarter Eagle
Cracking out is when a coin investor buys a graded coin and then cracks it out of its slab and sends it in for regrading in hope of upgrading the coin. This is not in any means a beginner tactic to coin collecting because it requires an expert eye and the ability to grade coins on the spot. The focus of this crack out guide will be Indian Head Quarter Eagles.
First here are some tips you should always consider before cracking out a coin:
- What is my win/loss (how much can I gain from an upgrade and how much can I lose from a downgrade)
- Does the coin have the strike, luster and detail for an upgrade?
- Is the added cost of certification and shipping worth the chance the coin comes back the same grade?
- When cracking out a coin beware of damaging the coin while handling it. (I have heard a few horror stories about people cracking a coin out then dropping it the second it is out of the holder and turning an MS 64 St. Double into a AU-55 St. Double.)
- Be kind and at the end of the year send back all your crack out slips so the coin populations can be redone.
So that is some of the basic knowledge for a more in depth look check out The Coin Collector’s Survival Manual
For the lesson on the Indian Head Quarter Eagle I have picked three dates I feel have a great upside/ downside ratio. The reason I picked the Indian Head Quarter Eagle is because of the way the coin is designed and the complexity the coin presents to the grader. The coin’s details are sunken in and the surfaces are leveled. The coin is graded by the ANA as follows:
MS-70: “A Flawless Coin Exactly as minted… Must have full mint luster”- ANA
MS-65 “No trace of wear except for some small blemishes. Has full mint luster. A few noticeable nicks or marks may be present.”- ANA
MS-63 “A coin with attractive mint luster but noticeable detracting contact marks or minor blemishes” -ANA
MS-60 “A strictly uncirculated coin with no trace of wear but with blemishes more obvious than for a MS-63″ May lack full mint luster and brilliance.”
From this you can notice that the difference between a MS-62 and a MS-63 would be minor if anything but the value swap is huge. Or from a MS-63 to 64.
By the numbers:
|
VALUE IN GRADE |
|||
| DATE & MINTMARK | MS- 61 | MS- 62 | MS-63 |
| 1909 | $390 | $650 | $2,000 |
| BUY THE MS-62 WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL AND THE EXPECTED RESULTS ARE AS FOLLOWS | -$280 (LOSS IN VALUE AND GRADING PLUS SHIPPING) | -$20 (FOR GRADING AND SHIPPING) | +1,330 (PROFIT FROM INCREASE IN VALUE LESS COST OF GRADING AND SHIPPING) |
| MS- 61 | MS- 62 | MS-63 | |
| 1912 | $390 | $625 | $2,100 |
| BUY THE MS-62 WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL AND THE EXPECTED RESULTS ARE AS FOLLOWS | -$255 (LOSS IN VALUE AND GRADING PLUS SHIPPING) | -$20 (FOR GRADING AND SHIPPING) | +1,455 (PROFIT FROM INCREASE IN VALUE LESS COST OF GRADING AND SHIPPING) |
| MS- 60 | MS- 61 | MS-62 | |
| 1914 | $400 | $700 | $2,150 |
| BUY THE MS-61 WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL | -$320 (LOSS IN VALUE AND GRADING PLUS SHIPPING) | -$20 (FOR GRADING AND SHIPPING) | +1,430 (PROFIT FROM INCREASE IN VALUE LESS COST OF GRADING AND SHIPPING) |
***Warning: no results are guaranteed do not do this if you cannot afford the downside risk. As always you can damage your coins easily and there is no safe way to crack coins out. Not for people who do not have expert coin experience!****
